I got a pizza steel. It’s a 16″ x 16″ x 1/4″ thick piece of steel for baking pizzas on. I thought about getting one nearly a year ago. put it off, told Dana it would be a good Xmas gift, then told her not to get one, then thought about it again, then got convinced by a friend to get one, and here we are.
I was originally turned off by the thought of having to heat it in the kitchen oven for 45 to 60 minutes, but damn… I just made some pizzas and yes, yes, it was totally worth it!
I ended up getting a Thermichef 1/4″ Deluxe Version, 16″x16″. (Okay, I actually got a Factory 2nd item, which was $10 cheaper, but same thing. Supposedly it has some blemishes but I didn’t notice.) The one mistake I made was that I should have maybe got a 16″ x 14″ because the 16″ depth sort of makes it ride up on the angled back part of the oven rack. Not a huge deal I guess. And damn, that things is heavy!
I had planned on screwing around with it over the weekend but honestly I could not wait. I had dough I put in the freezer about two weeks ago, and I put it in the fridge before I went to work, then put it on the counter when I got home for about 45 minutes while the oven heated up. I had grabbed some cornmeal at The Outpost (as I could not find semolina flour) but didn’t use it because someone recommended parchment paper. I should also note I don’t have a pizza peel. The parchment paper worked well. I just made the pizza on the paper then slid it (from a cutting board) onto the steel.
I’ve since read a tip that you can bake on parchment paper for a few minutes then pull it out so the pizza is directly on the steel. I may try that next time. The parchment paper makes “Launching” the pizza onto the steel easy, especially if you don’t have a peel.
Oh, I divided the dough into three small crusts, one Dana and I ate, one I ate, and one I packed for my lunch the next day. I should also note that Dana declared it the best crust made in this house that she ever tasted. (And she can be pretty particular about her crusts!) And yes I threw these together quick and haphazardly so they are not beautiful looking.
I was able to grab the parchment paper to pull the pizza out when done as well, so that was all good. I still need to figure out exact baking times. I did about 4 minutes, then turned the oven to broil on high for another few minutes.
And the results? Damn, that crust was the best I’ve ever made, and I’ve been making pizza crust at home for nearly 20 years. Seriously, it was good. Why the hell did I put this off for so long!? I’ve been reading The Elements of Pizza: Unlocking the Secrets to World-Class Pies at Home and there are a ton of tips and tricks for better dough/crust, but my regular old recipe on a pizza steel turned out amazing.
And I mean, I’m not done… I still have a lot to learn, and a lot more experiments, but I had no idea my first attempt would turn out so well. Cheers!
Just one more note about the photo above. The cutting board was a gift from my dear friend Maks and the pizza cutter was given to Dana from the husband of a colleague who turned the handle on his lathe. Neat!
Note: This post contains an Affiliate Link. Read More.